David Ashman

Challenging unfair fines given to cyclists

Fundraising for Cyclists' Defence Fund
£2,700
raised of £2,000 target
Donations cannot currently be made to this page
Challenging unfair fines, 4 September 2017
We defend the rights of cyclists in order to make cycling accessible and enjoyable

Story

Message from Alex Paxton 'I'm immensely grateful for the CDF's support, and of course all of you that have donated! Thank you very much indeed'

In August, Alex Paxton was issued with a fixed penalty notice (FPN) for failing to stop behind the Advanced Stop Line (ASL) at a set of traffic lights. He did not stop behind the line (i.e. in the cycle box) because a car was illegally positioned in the box. For his own safety he positioned himself ahead of the car, past the white line. A police officer witnessed this incident and radioed a colleague, who stopped Alex further down the road and gave him the FPN. This officer had not seen the alleged offence, so could not assess the greater risk Alex would have been in had he positioned himself behind the white line, and therefore did not accept Alex's justification of his actions. 

The Highway Code encourages cyclists to 'use cycle routes, advanced stop lines, cycle boxes and toucan crossings unless at the time is it unsafe to do so'. Alex's adoption of a safer position is therefore entirely justified.  

There have been several cases recently of cyclists being given on the spot fines for stopping in front of ASLs, despite there not being room in the box because a car has taken the space. 

Alex wants to contest the FPN and CDF has decided to fund the legal challenge in a bid to create a precedent that will hopefully stop future spurious fines being given out by police officers. 

Any funds raised in excess of the £2000 this challenge is expected to cost will be used to support other legal challenges that defend the rights of cyclists.

Thank you for your support.

Share this story

Help David Ashman

Sharing this page with your friends could help raise up to 3x more in donations

You can also help by sharing this link on

About the charity

CTC's Cyclists' Defence Fund raises awareness and understanding of the law relating to cycling in order to encourage and facilitate safe cycling in the UK. CDF provides guidance on the law, researches the effectiveness of the law, and supports cyclists' legal cases.

Donation summary

Total raised
£2,699.50
+ £150.38 Gift Aid
Online donations
£2,699.50
Offline donations
£0.00

* Charities pay a small fee for our service. Find out how much it is and what we do for it.